Honor Roll: The Best 20 Hospitals for 2016-2017
November 24, 2016
In August 2016, U.S. News and World Report announced their findings for the top 20, “Honor Roll” hospitals in the United States. These rankings, which have been collected annually since 1990, signify the best hospitals for quality and performance, from complex situations to common surgeries and care of all kinds.
Each year, these lists not only help patients find quality centers for their inpatient care needs, but they help physicians, nurses, healthcare administration, and healthcare support staff find hospital jobs that meet and exceed their own expectations for performance and patient care.
To earn a coveted spot on the 2016-2017 Honor Roll, eligible hospitals were ranked and given points based on if and how well they ranked in a specific set of 16 specialities, as well as how many “high performing” ratings they received in common hospital procedures and conditions. The top 20 hospitals with the greatest combined total, made the following list and scored the following points:
Ranking and scoring the honor roll list involves looking into the U.S. News and World Report’s 16 Best Hospital Rankings by Specialty, as well as their Best Hospitals Procedures and Conditions Rating. Acquiring a top-ranking honor roll designation is determined by the combined efforts of these two lists, as well as eligibility and various other factors.
To earn a spot as one of the best hospitals for a specific specialty, measurable data and/or the hospital’s reputation — in 16 speciality care areas — are reviewed to form the short-list of hospitals that excel in treating complex medical cases and emergencies.
Twelve of these specialities are data-driven, and include the specialities of: cancer, cardiology & heart surgery, diabetes & endocrinology, gastroenterology & GI surgery, gynecology, nephrology, neurology & neurosurgery, orthopedics, pulmonology, urology; and ear, nose & throat.
The results are based mostly on objective data, including patient death rates in especially challenging cases, patient safety, and other areas of measurable data. Results are also scored and based on the three most recent year’s worth of physician-supplied surveys on reputation, in which physicians vote for the hospitals that they believe to be the best in their specialty for difficult cases.
The remaining four specialities (ophthalmology, psychiatry, rehabilitation, and rheumatology) are determined entirely by these physician-supplied reputation surveys.
The list for best hospitals regarding procedures and conditions, instead, focuses on individual procedures and conditions — whether complex or not. This study evaluates almost every hospital in the United States that admits patients for what are considered nine of the most common procedures and conditions: colon cancer surgery, lung cancer surgery, heart bypass surgery, aortic valve surgery, abdominal aortic aneurysm repair, hip replacement, knee replacement, heart failure, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
The hospital’s reputation for specialities is not a part of this study (as in the previous list), and results produced are considered ratings (not numerical rankings), where individual hospitals are rated as high, average, or below average for performance surrounding each procedure or condition.
To compete for a spot on the Honor Roll, hospitals were given points for ranking in the speciality-driven list, as well as if they rated as high performing in any of the nine procedures and conditions. Hospitals with the most points — and within the top 20 — found themselves on the Honor Roll. Points were awarded as follows:
The 12 Best Hospital Specialties (Data-Driven):
#1-ranked hospital received 25 Honor Roll points.
#2-ranked hospital received 24 points.
#3 through #20-ranked hospitals received 23-6 points, respectively and consecutively.
#21 through #50-ranked hospitals all received 5 points.
All 50 hospitals received points, but no hospitals earned the #1 position for all 12 specialties — if they had, they would have received 300 points.
The 4 Best Hospitals Specialties (Reputation-Driven):
#1-ranked hospital received 10 Honor Roll points.
#2-ranked hospital received 9 points.
#3 through #9-ranked hospitals received 8-2 points, respectively and consecutively.
#10 through all ranked hospitals received 1 point.
No hospitals earned the #1 position for all 4 reputation-based specialties, but if they had, they would have received 40 points.
The 9 Best Hospitals Procedures and Conditions:
Each “high performing” rating earned each hospital 12 Honor Roll points.
Sixty-three hospitals rated high performing in all nine procedures and conditions, earning the full, potential total of 108 points.
The 2016-2017 Honor Roll is composed of the top 20 hospitals that earned the most points from these lists, evaluations, surveys, and more. 448 total points were possible.
To learn more about the individual hospitals that earned the top ten spots on the list, including what specialities they rank for, where they rank for those individual specialties, and more, check out our blog: Top 10 Hospitals in the U.S. Finally, keep in mind that the Honor Roll’s focus on quality care is evolving. Be sure to check back annually for the most up-to-date studies on the best hospitals in the United States.